Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India (2015)

Supreme Court of India · (2016) 5 SCC 1 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

By a 4:1 majority, the Court struck down the Constitution (Ninety-ninth Amendment) Act, 2014 and the National Judicial Appointments Commission Act, 2014, holding that the NJAC mechanism damaged the independence of the judiciary, a basic feature. The collegium system was revived. Justice Chelameswar dissented.

Facts

  • Parliament enacted the 99th Constitutional Amendment and the NJAC Act to replace the collegium with a six-member National Judicial Appointments Commission including executive and civil-society nominees.
  • Writ petitions challenged the amendment and the Act as violative of the basic structure, particularly judicial independence and separation of powers.

Issues

  • Whether the 99th Amendment and the NJAC Act violate the basic structure by compromising judicial independence in appointments.
  • Whether the collegium system revived upon invalidation of the NJAC.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Independence of judiciary as basic feature

The majority held that judicial primacy in appointments is integral to independence of the judiciary and therefore to the basic structure; the NJAC’s composition allowed non-judicial members to block or dilute that primacy.

Revival of collegium

Upon striking down the 99th Amendment and the NJAC Act, the collegium system under the Second and Third Judges Cases stood revived, subject to later administrative efforts to improve transparency.

Decision

99th Amendment and NJAC Act declared unconstitutional. Collegium restored. Chelameswar J. dissented, favouring a reformed, more transparent mechanism.

Ratio decidendi

A constitutional amendment that replaces judicial primacy in appointments with a commission in which the executive and nominated members can override or stalemate the judges damages the independence of the judiciary and is void.

Exam points

  • 4:1 majority; NJAC and 99th Amendment struck down.
  • Judicial independence / primacy in appointments = basic feature.
  • Collegium revived (Second + Third Judges Cases).
  • Chelameswar J. dissent is frequently contrasted in answers.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, NJAC, Collegium, Judicial Independence, Basic Structure

All judgments