Hira Lal v. Kalyan Mal (1998)
Supreme Court of India · (1998) 1 SCC 278 · 2-Judge Bench
Summary
Landmark decision on amendment of pleadings under Order VI Rule 17 CPC. Settled that an amendment to a written statement cannot be permitted if its effect is to withdraw a clear, unequivocal judicial admission made in favor of the plaintiff, thereby displacing the plaintiff accrued rights.
Facts
- The respondent filed a partition suit claiming that certain properties were joint family properties.
- In their original written statement, the defendants expressly admitted that 7 out of 10 suit properties were joint family assets.
- Subsequently, the defendants filed an application under Order VI Rule 17 CPC seeking to amend the written statement to withdraw the admission and claim that all properties were self-acquired.
- The High Court allowed the amendment, against which the plaintiff appealed to the Supreme Court.
Issues
- Whether a defendant can be allowed under Order VI Rule 17 CPC to amend a written statement so as to withdraw a clear admission of fact made in favor of the plaintiff.
- What are the limitations on the liberal doctrine of amending written statements.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Withdrawal of admission vs taking inconsistent pleas
Majmudar, J. explained that while a defendant in a written statement may take alternative or inconsistent pleas, he cannot be permitted to withdraw a clear and categorical admission of fact that has vested a valuable legal right in the plaintiff.
Displacement of plaintiff case causes irreparable injury
Permitting the withdrawal of admission would completely sabotage the partition claim and force the plaintiff to prove facts that were previously admitted. Such an amendment cannot be allowed in law.
Decision
Appeal allowed. High Court order set aside; defendants application under Order VI Rule 17 to withdraw admissions rejected.
Ratio decidendi
Under Order VI Rule 17 CPC, a party cannot be permitted by way of amendment to withdraw a clear, categorical admission made in a written statement which confers a valuable right upon the plaintiff, if such withdrawal displaces the plaintiff case and causes irreversible prejudice.
Exam points
- Order VI Rule 17 CPC amendment principles regarding written statements.
- Clear judicial admissions cannot be retracted or withdrawn through amendment.
- Inconsistent pleas are permissible in defence, but not the withdrawal of an admission that prejudices the plaintiff.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, CPC, Order VI Rule 17, Pleadings, Written Statement, Admission