Pleadings (Orders VI–VIII)
Code of Civil Procedure (CPC) · Orders VI–VIII
Orders VI–VIII: pleadings generally, plaint and r. 11 rejection, written statement, set-off and counter-claim.
Study notes
Introduction
Pleadings are the facts, not the evidence. Order VI is the general law. Order VII is the plaint. Order VIII is the written statement, set-off and counter-claim.
Essentials
Order VI r. 2 — material facts, not evidence. r. 17 amendment: all amendments that are necessary to determine the real questions, subject to the 2002 proviso on delayed amendment after trial has begun.
Order VII r. 1 — particulars of the plaint. r. 11 — rejection: no cause of action, undervalued, under-stamped, barred by law, not in duplicate, failure of r. 9.
Order VIII — specific denial; set-off; counter-claim treated as a plaint.
Illustration
Time-barred money claim with no acknowledgement pleaded. Reject under Order VII r. 11(d).
Fail-illustration
Defendant wants r. 11 because he has a strong defence on facts. That is a trial issue, not rejection.
Authority
Saleem Bhai (2003) 1 SCC 557 — r. 11 is decided on the plaint.
T. Arivandandam AIR 1977 SC 2421 — meaningless claims must be nipped.
Revajeetu Builders (2009) 10 SCC 84 — amendment factors.
Close with Orders VI–VIII CPC, 1908.
Leading cases
- Saleem Bhai v. State of Maharashtra (2003), (2003) 1 SCC 557 — Order VII r. 11 is read on the plaint.
- T. Arivandandam v. T.V. Satyapal (1977), AIR 1977 SC 2421 — A cleverly drafted illusion of a cause of action must be rejected.
Questions & answers
Write a note on rejection of plaint.
Order VII r. 11. Grounds (a)–(f). Test is the plaint itself. Rejection is not a decision on merits. Saleem Bhai; Arivandandam. Cite Order VII r. 11 CPC, 1908.
Plaintiff sues on a facially time-barred contract. Defendant moves r. 11. Decide.
Issue. Is the suit barred on the face of the plaint?
Rule. r. 11(d).
Application. If no acknowledgement is pleaded, reject. If limitation is a mixed fact, go to trial.
Conclusion. Order VII r. 11 CPC.
Exam tips
- r. 11 is not a mini-trial of the defence.