P.V. Narasimha Rao v. State (JMM Bribery Case) (1998)

Supreme Court of India · (1998) 4 SCC 626 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

Controversial 5-judge Constitution Bench decision interpreting parliamentary privileges under Article 105(2) and Article 194(2) of the Constitution. By a 3:2 majority, held that Members of Parliament who took bribes and voted in accordance with the corrupt agreement were immune from criminal prosecution because their vote was cast in Parliament, whereas members who took bribes but did not vote enjoyed no immunity. (Overruled in 2024 by 7-judge bench in Sita Soren).

Facts

  • In July 1993, the minority Congress Government led by Prime Minister P.V. Narasimha Rao faced a no-confidence motion in the Lok Sabha.
  • Bribes of several lakhs of rupees were allegedly paid to MPs of the Jharkhand Mukti Morcha (JMM) and Janata Dal to vote against the motion.
  • The MPs voted against the motion, defeating it. One MP, Ajit Singh, allegedly accepted the bribe money but did not attend Parliament to vote.
  • The CBI registered corruption cases under the PC Act. The accused MPs claimed absolute constitutional immunity under Article 105(2).

Issues

  • Does the parliamentary immunity under Article 105(2) ("in respect of anything said or any vote given by him in Parliament") protect an MP from criminal prosecution for taking a bribe to vote.
  • Is there an irrational distinction between an MP who takes a bribe and votes, versus an MP who takes a bribe and does not vote.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Majority ruling on broad literal interpretation of Article 105(2)

Bharucha, J. (for the 3-judge majority) held that the words "in respect of anything said or any vote given" must receive a broad literal construction. The vote cast was the proximate fruit of the bribe; therefore, prosecuting the MP who voted impinged upon the vote given in Parliament. Those MPs were granted constitutional immunity.

The anomaly regarding non-voters

The majority held that an MP who took a bribe but did not vote (like Ajit Singh) did not cast a vote in Parliament and was therefore not protected by Article 105(2), creating the bizarre anomaly that a corrupt MP who faithfully executed his corrupt bargain was immune, while one who repented was prosecutable.

Decision

Appeals allowed in part by 3:2 majority. Corrupt MPs who voted against the no-confidence motion held immune from prosecution under Article 105(2). (Overruled by Sita Soren in 2024).

Ratio decidendi

Under the original majority interpretation of Article 105(2) of the Constitution, an MP who accepted a bribe to vote in a particular manner and subsequently cast that vote in Parliament enjoyed absolute immunity from criminal prosecution in courts of law. (This ruling has been expressly overruled by the 7-judge Constitution Bench in Sita Soren v. Union of India).

Exam points

  • The controversial 1998 majority interpretation of Article 105(2).
  • The paradox of immunizing bribe-takers who voted while prosecuting non-voters.
  • Expressly overruled in 2024 by 7-judge bench in Sita Soren v. Union of India.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 105, Parliamentary Privilege, Bribery, JMM Case

All judgments