Raja Ram Pal v. Hon'ble Speaker, Lok Sabha (2007)
Supreme Court of India · (2007) 3 SCC 184 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
In the cash-for-query matter, the Court held that the expulsion of Members of Parliament by the House is open to judicial review on limited constitutional grounds, and that parliamentary privileges under Article 105 are not a source of unlimited, unreviewable power.
Facts
- Following a television exposé on acceptance of money for asking questions in Parliament, a committee recommended expulsion of certain MPs.
- The House expelled the members; writ petitions challenged the expulsion as violative of constitutional limits on privileges and of principles of natural justice.
Issues
- Whether expulsion of a Member of Parliament is subject to judicial review.
- What is the scope of parliamentary privilege under Article 105 vis-à-vis fundamental rights and basic constitutional norms?
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Privileges are not absolute
The Court held that parliamentary privileges are subject to the Constitution; they cannot be exercised in a manner that destroys constitutional limitations or basic features.
Limited judicial review of expulsion
While courts will not sit as a court of appeal over every internal parliamentary decision, expulsion is open to judicial review on grounds such as illegality, unconstitutionality, and violation of fundamental constitutional norms.
Decision
Judicial review of expulsion was affirmed within limits. The judgment is a leading authority on the boundary between parliamentary privilege and constitutionalism.
Ratio decidendi
Parliamentary privileges exist within the Constitution, not above it; drastic actions such as expulsion of members remain amenable to judicial review on constitutional grounds.
Exam points
- Cash-for-query / expulsion of MPs context.
- Privileges under Article 105 are not unreviewable.
- Limited judicial review of expulsion.
- Often contrasted with exclusive cognisance doctrines.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Parliament, Privileges, Judicial Review