Rupa Ashok Hurra v. Ashok Hurra (2002)
Supreme Court of India · (2002) 4 SCC 388 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
The 5-Judge Constitution Bench created the novel procedural remedy of "Curative Petition" to prevent abuse of the Supreme Court’s process and to cure a gross miscarriage of justice after a review petition under Article 137 has been dismissed. The Court held that under Article 142 inherent powers, a final judgment can be re-examined on narrow, rigorous grounds: violation of natural justice or apprehension of bias.
Facts
- A matrimonial dispute between husband and wife reached the Supreme Court, where a decree of divorce by mutual consent was granted under Article 142 despite the wife having withdrawn her consent before the decree.
- Her review petition was dismissed.
- She moved a writ petition challenging the validity of the Supreme Court’s own final judgment, raising the fundamental question whether a judgment of the apex court can ever be challenged or cured after dismissal of review.
Issues
- Whether an aggrieved person is entitled to any relief against a final judgment/order of the Supreme Court after dismissal of a review petition.
- Under what conditions and procedural safeguards can the Supreme Court reconsider its final orders.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Reconciling finality with correction of grave injustice
Quadri, J. held that while finality of judgment is essential, the duty to do complete justice under Article 142 is superior where there has been a manifest miscarriage of justice.
Grounds and procedural filters for Curative Petitions
Curative relief is restricted to: (1) violation of principles of natural justice where a party was not heard, or (2) where a judge failed to disclose bias. The petition must be certified by a Senior Advocate and circulated to the three senior-most judges and the judges who passed the original order.
Decision
Curative petition mechanism formally instituted with strict procedural safeguards.
Ratio decidendi
Under its inherent powers and Article 142, the Supreme Court may reconsider a final judgment through a curative petition if there was a violation of natural justice or real apprehension of bias.
Exam points
- Originated the "Curative Petition" in Indian jurisprudence.
- Grounds strictly limited to: breach of natural justice or judicial bias.
- Mandatory Senior Advocate certification and circulation to three senior-most judges.
- Exemplary costs if the petition is found frivolous.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 142, Curative Petition, Natural Justice