Supreme Court Advocates-on-Record Association v. Union of India (1993)
Supreme Court of India · (1993) 4 SCC 441 · 9-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
A 9-Judge Bench held that the Chief Justice of India has primacy in the appointment of judges of the Supreme Court and High Courts, and that the opinion of the CJI means the opinion formed in consultation with a collegium of senior judges—establishing the collegium system in substance.
Facts
- After S.P. Gupta (First Judges Case) had reduced the primacy of the CJI in appointments, fresh petitions raised the meaning of "consultation" under Articles 124 and 217.
- The Court reconsidered the balance between the executive and the judiciary in judicial appointments and transfers.
Issues
- Whether the Chief Justice of India has primacy in the appointment of Supreme Court and High Court judges.
- What "consultation" under Articles 124 and 217 requires.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Primacy of the CJI
The Court held that in the event of a conflict, the opinion of the CJI has primacy in the appointment process, overruling the contrary approach of the First Judges Case on this aspect.
Collegium as institutional opinion
The opinion of the CJI is not the individual opinion of the office-holder alone but an institutional opinion formed in consultation with the collegium of senior-most judges.
Decision
Primacy of the CJI in judicial appointments was restored and the collegium method was constitutionalised through interpretation. The Third Judges Case (1998) later clarified the collegium’s composition and consultation process.
Ratio decidendi
Independence of the judiciary requires primacy of the CJI in appointments; "consultation" under Articles 124 and 217 is meaningful only when the CJI’s institutional opinion has primacy over the executive in case of conflict.
Exam points
- Second Judges Case = collegium primacy of CJI.
- Overruled First Judges Case on primacy of executive.
- CJI’s opinion = collegium’s institutional opinion.
- Third Judges Case (1998) later clarified numbers/process.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Collegium, Judicial Independence, Basic Structure