Shilpa Sailesh v. Varun Sreenivasan (2023)

Supreme Court of India · (2023) 7 SCC 1 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

The 5-Judge Constitution Bench held that the Supreme Court has the constitutional power under Article 142 to dissolve a marriage on the ground of "irretrievable breakdown of marriage", even if one of the spouses opposes the decree. The Court further held that it can waive the statutory six-month cooling-off period under Section 13B(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 to do complete justice where the marriage is emotionally dead beyond reconciliation.

Facts

  • A batch of transfer petitions and appeals raised common questions regarding the scope of the Supreme Court’s powers under Article 142 in matrimonial disputes.
  • Couples whose marriages had completely collapsed and who had lived separately for years or decades were entangled in prolonged litigation because "irretrievable breakdown of marriage" is not an enumerated statutory ground of divorce under the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
  • The matter was referred to a Constitution Bench to determine whether Article 142 can be exercised to grant divorce where reconciliation is impossible, and whether the statutory waiting period in mutual consent divorce can be bypassed.

Issues

  • Whether the Supreme Court can grant divorce on the ground of irretrievable breakdown of marriage in exercise of its plenary powers under Article 142 of the Constitution.
  • Whether the Supreme Court can dispense with the six-month statutory waiting period prescribed under Section 13B(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955.
  • What guidelines must the Court observe to determine whether a marriage is irretrievably broken down.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Plenary scope of Article 142 in Matrimonial Disputes

Sanjiv Khanna, J. held that Article 142 is not bounded by statutory procedural limitations when doing complete justice. Forcing parties to remain married when emotional bonding is non-existent and relations have soured irreparably amounts to cruelty.

Illustrative Factors for Irretrievable Breakdown

The Court laid down factors to determine irretrievable breakdown: (1) period of time the parties had cohabited after marriage; (2) when the parties last cohabited; (3) the nature of allegations made by the parties; (4) orders passed in legal proceedings; (5) attempts at settlement and mediation; and (6) period of separation (ordinarily, continuous separation of six or more years).

Power to dispense with Section 13B(2) cooling-off period

The six-month period under Section 13B(2) is directory, not mandatory. Where efforts at mediation have failed and parties are determined to separate, the Supreme Court can waive the waiting period and grant instant mutual consent divorce.

Decision

Constitution Bench answered the reference affirmatively; established power to grant divorce on irretrievable breakdown and waive Section 13B(2) period.

Ratio decidendi

Under Article 142 of the Constitution, the Supreme Court has the jurisdiction to dissolve a marriage on the ground of irretrievable breakdown and to waive the statutory waiting period under Section 13B(2) of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 to do complete justice.

Exam points

  • 5-Judge Constitution Bench authoritative decision on irretrievable breakdown of marriage.
  • Supreme Court can dissolve marriage on irretrievable breakdown under Article 142 even without both parties' consent.
  • Power to waive the 6-month waiting period under Section 13B(2) HMA affirmed.
  • High Courts and family courts CANNOT grant divorce on irretrievable breakdown; this power belongs strictly to the Supreme Court under Article 142.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Family Law, Article 142, Irretrievable Breakdown, Section 13B HMA, Divorce

All judgments