Sita Soren v. Union of India (2024)
Supreme Court of India · (2024) 5 SCC 629 · 7-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
Unanimous 7-judge Constitution Bench judgment unanimously overruling the 1998 majority ruling in P.V. Narasimha Rao. Held that parliamentary privilege and legislative immunity under Articles 105(2) and 194(2) do not protect Members of Parliament or State Legislators from criminal prosecution for accepting bribes to cast a vote or deliver a speech. Ruled that corruption and bribery subvert democratic governance and can never be claimed as a privilege.
Facts
- Sita Soren, a Member of the Jharkhand Legislative Assembly, allegedly accepted a bribe to cast her vote in favor of an independent candidate in the 2012 Rajya Sabha elections.
- However, she ended up voting for her own party candidate instead.
- When the CBI filed a chargesheet under the Prevention of Corruption Act, she claimed immunity under Article 194(2) relying on the P.V. Narasimha Rao precedent.
- The Jharkhand High Court dismissed her plea, and on appeal, the Supreme Court referred the matter to a 7-judge Constitution Bench to reconsider the correctness of P.V. Narasimha Rao.
Issues
- Does the parliamentary immunity under Article 105(2) and Article 194(2) protect a legislator from criminal prosecution on a charge of bribery for voting or speaking in the House.
- Was the majority decision in P.V. Narasimha Rao v. State (1998) correctly decided.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Parliamentary privileges are functional, not personal shields
Chandrachud, C.J. held that parliamentary privileges are not individual exemptions or badges of feudal nobility. They are functional immunities granted to ensure that the House functions fearlessly. Bribery does not enhance the deliberative capacity of Parliament; on the contrary, it pollutes the legislative process and subverts democratic integrity.
Offence of bribery is independent of the vote cast
The Court held that the offence of bribery under the Prevention of Corruption Act is complete the moment the illegal gratification is accepted or agreed to be accepted. It is entirely immaterial whether the legislator ultimately voted in accordance with the bribe, voted against it, or did not vote at all. P.V. Narasimha Rao was unanimously overruled.
Decision
Appeal dismissed. P.V. Narasimha Rao v. State overruled. Held that legislators accepting bribes for speeches or votes enjoy zero immunity under Articles 105(2) and 194(2).
Ratio decidendi
Under Articles 105(2) and 194(2) of the Constitution, parliamentary privileges and immunities do not extend to shield a Member of Parliament or State Legislature from criminal prosecution for bribery in connection with their speech or vote. The offence of bribery is complete upon acceptance of gratification, independent of the vote cast. P.V. Narasimha Rao v. State is overruled.
Exam points
- Historic 7-judge Constitution Bench overruling P.V. Narasimha Rao (1998).
- Absolute bar on claiming parliamentary privilege for bribery under Articles 105/194.
- Bribery offence is complete upon receipt of gratification, regardless of the vote.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Article 105, Article 194, Bribery, Sita Soren, Privilege