S.P. Gupta v. Union of India (1981)
Supreme Court of India · 1981 Supp SCC 87 · 7-Judge Constitution Bench
Summary
The 7-Judge Constitution Bench revolutionized Indian procedural jurisprudence by liberalizing the traditional rule of locus standi, laying the conceptual foundation for Public Interest Litigation (PIL). On judicial appointments, the majority held that "consultation" under Articles 124(2) and 217(1) does not mean "concurrence", granting executive primacy over judicial appointments (later overruled in Second Judges).
Facts
- During 1980-81, the Union Law Minister issued a circular seeking consent of Additional Judges of High Courts for transfer to other High Courts, and non-extension of tenure of several Additional Judges was challenged.
- Practicing advocates filed writ petitions challenging the circular and non-appointment.
- The Government raised preliminary objections that practicing lawyers had no personal injury or locus standi to maintain the petitions, and claimed privilege under Section 123 Evidence Act regarding appointment correspondence.
Issues
- Whether practicing advocates have locus standi to challenge executive actions affecting the independence of the judiciary.
- Whether "consultation" with the Chief Justice of India under Article 124(2) and 217(1) means concurrence.
- Whether the State can claim privilege over correspondence concerning judicial appointments.
Provisions involved
Reasoning
Liberalisation of Locus Standi and Birth of PIL
Bhagwati, J. held that where a legal wrong or legal injury is caused to a person or to a determinate class of persons who by reason of poverty, disability, or socially/economically disadvantaged position cannot approach the court, any member of the public acting bona fide can maintain an action under Article 32 or 226.
Interpretation of "consultation" under Article 124/217
The majority held that consultation does not mean concurrence; the Central Government is not bound to accept the advice of the CJI, giving executive primacy in judicial appointments.
Decision
Locus standi of lawyers was upheld; PIL doctrine formalized; executive primacy in judicial appointments was recognized.
Ratio decidendi
Traditional locus standi is relaxed for public interest litigation where disadvantaged persons suffer legal injury; "consultation" in judicial appointments does not imply executive subservience to judicial advice.
Exam points
- Inaugurated modern PIL doctrine and relaxed locus standi in India.
- Known as the "First Judges Case".
- Affirmed executive primacy in judicial appointments (later overruled in 1993).
- Rejected State claim of secrecy over appointment files, promoting transparency.
Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, PIL, Locus Standi, First Judges Case