K. Veeraswami v. Union of India (1991)

Supreme Court of India · (1991) 3 SCC 655 · 5-Judge Constitution Bench

Summary

The 5-Judge Constitution Bench held that Judges of High Courts and the Supreme Court are "public servants" within the meaning of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947/1988 and can be prosecuted for corruption and disproportionate assets. However, to safeguard judicial independence from executive harassment, the Court mandated that no FIR shall be registered against a High Court or Supreme Court Judge without prior mandatory consultation with the Chief Justice of India.

Facts

  • The Central Bureau of Investigation (CBI) registered an FIR under Section 5(1)(e) of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947 against Justice K. Veeraswami, the former Chief Justice of the Madras High Court, alleging possession of assets disproportionate to his known sources of income.
  • Justice Veeraswami challenged the proceedings in the High Court and Supreme Court, contending that superior court judges are constitutional functionaries and not "public servants" subject to police investigation.
  • He argued that the only constitutional method to discipline or remove a superior court judge is impeachment by Parliament under Article 124(4) and 124(5).

Issues

  • Whether a High Court Judge or Chief Justice is a "public servant" under Section 2 of the Prevention of Corruption Act, 1947.
  • Who is the "competent authority" to grant sanction for the prosecution of a superior court judge under Section 6 of the Act.
  • What constitutional procedural safeguards must be observed before investigating and prosecuting a superior court judge for corruption.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

Superior Court Judges are Public Servants

Shetty, J. for the majority held that superior court judges perform public judicial functions and are paid from the Consolidated Fund. The phrase "public servant" includes anyone holding an office in virtue of which he is authorized to perform any public duty; judges are not exempt from the criminal law of corruption.

Mandatory Prior Consultation with Chief Justice of India

To prevent malicious police investigations or executive intimidation of honest judges, the Court laid down a binding constitutional condition: no criminal case or FIR shall be registered against a superior court judge, and no investigation shall proceed, without prior consultation with the Chief Justice of India. If the CJI advises against prosecution, no case can be filed.

Decision

High Court and Supreme Court Judges held amenable to Prevention of Corruption Act; mandatory CJI prior consultation safeguard established.

Ratio decidendi

Superior court judges are public servants under anti-corruption statutes, but prior consultation with the Chief Justice of India is a mandatory constitutional prerequisite before registering an FIR or initiating criminal investigation against a judge.

Exam points

  • Held Supreme Court and High Court judges are "public servants" under the Prevention of Corruption Act.
  • Impeachment under Article 124(4) and criminal prosecution for corruption can co-exist.
  • Prior mandatory consultation with the Chief Justice of India before registering FIR against a judge.
  • Sanctioning authority is the President acting in consultation with the CJI.

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, Constitution, Judiciary, Anti-Corruption, CJI Consultation, Veeraswami

All judgments