Decree & Execution

Code of Civil Procedure (CPC)

s. 2(2) decree. ss. 36–74 and Order XXI execution. s. 47 keeps execution questions inside execution.

Study notes

Introduction

A decree is the formal expression of an adjudication that conclusively determines the rights of the parties (s. 2(2)). Without execution it is paper.

Essentials

s. 38 — court which passed the decree or the court to which it is sent.

s. 47 — questions between the parties relating to execution, discharge or satisfaction — executing court, not a fresh suit.

s. 51 — modes: payment, possession, arrest, attachment, appointment of receiver.

s. 56 — no arrest of women on a money decree.

s. 60 — what can be attached; statutory exemptions.

Order XXI — the working procedure.

Illustration

Money decree unpaid. Decree-holder files execution, attaches a bank account, and seeks sale of a plot if needed.

Fail-illustration

Stranger claims the attached house. That is a claim petition under Order XXI rr. 58–59, not s. 47.

Authority

Harnandrai Badridas AIR 1973 SC 2423 — s. 47 avoids a second round.

Jolly George Varghese AIR 1980 SC 470 — arrest is not a punishment for honest poverty.

Close with ss. 47, 51, 60 and Order XXI CPC, 1908.

Leading cases

  • Harnandrai Badridas v. Debidutt Bhagwati Prasad (1973), AIR 1973 SC 2423 — Execution questions stay in the executing court.
  • Jolly George Varghese v. Bank of Cochin (1980), AIR 1980 SC 470 — Civil imprisonment is not for honest inability to pay.

Questions & answers

Explain s. 47 CPC.

Questions between parties relating to execution, discharge or satisfaction are decided by the executing court. No separate suit. Harnandrai Badridas. Cite s. 47 and Order XXI CPC, 1908.

Decree-holder starts a new suit alleging the judgment-debtor has already paid a third person. Advise.

Issue. Fresh suit or execution?

Rule. s. 47.

Application. Payment and satisfaction are execution questions. Return the plaintiff to the executing court.

Conclusion. s. 47 CPC, 1908.

Exam tips

  • Name the mode under s. 51. Then open Order XXI.