Appeals, Review, Revision
s. 96 first appeal. s. 100 second appeal. s. 104 / Order XLIII orders. s. 114 review. s. 115 revision.
Study notes
Introduction
Choose the correct doorway. First appeal (s. 96) is on facts and law from an original decree. Second appeal (s. 100) is only on a substantial question of law. Appeals from orders follow s. 104 and Order XLIII. Review (s. 114 / Order XLVII) is by the same court on a narrow ground. Revision (s. 115) watches jurisdiction where no appeal lies.
Illustration
Trial court decrees after evidence. First appeal under s. 96 can re-appreciate facts.
Fail-illustration
Loser wants the High Court in second appeal to say the trial court believed the wrong witness. That is not a substantial question of law.
Authority
Banarsi v. Ram Phal (2003) 1 SCC 727 — first appeal is the last court of fact.
Santosh Hazari (2001) 3 SCC 179 — substantial question of law.
S.S. Khanna AIR 1964 SC 497 — revision is jurisdictional.
BCCI v. Netaji Cricket Club (2005) 4 SCC 741 — review is not an appeal in disguise.
Close with ss. 96, 100, 114 and 115 CPC, 1908.
Distinctions
Appeal, review, revision
- Forum: Superior court / Review: same court. Revision: High Court
- Width: s. 96 facts+law; s. 100 only substantial law / Narrow — apparent error or jurisdiction
- Appeal
- Review / revision
Leading cases
- Santosh Hazari v. Purushottam Tiwari (2001), (2001) 3 SCC 179 — Defined substantial question of law.
- Banarsi v. Ram Phal (2003), (2003) 1 SCC 727 — First appellate court must weigh the evidence.
Questions & answers
Distinguish first appeal and second appeal.
s. 96: original decree; facts and law; not from a consent decree. s. 100: appellate decree; substantial question of law must be formulated. Banarsi; Santosh Hazari. Cite ss. 96 and 100 CPC, 1908.
High Court in second appeal re-appreciates oral evidence and reverses. Discuss.
Issue. Is that permitted?
Rule. s. 100 — substantial question of law only. Kondiba Kadam (1999) 3 SCC 722.
Application. Re-trying witnesses is a first-appeal function.
Conclusion. The second appeal is unsustainable unless a legal question was first framed.
Exam tips
- Write the doorway in the first sentence: 96, 100, 104, 114 or 115.