Kamlesh Verma v. Mayawati (2013)

Supreme Court of India · (2013) 8 SCC 320 · 2-Judge Bench

Summary

The leading modern authority summarizing the comprehensive principles governing review jurisdiction under Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC and Article 137 of the Constitution. Codified two exhaustive lists: grounds when review is maintainable (error apparent, new discovery) and grounds when review is strictly not maintainable (rehearing of arguments, minor omission).

Facts

  • A review petition was filed seeking review of the Supreme Court judgment quashing the CBI disproportionate assets investigation against former UP Chief Minister Mayawati.
  • The petitioner contended that vital facts regarding statutory sanctions were overlooked by the original bench.
  • The Supreme Court utilized the occasion to author an exhaustive treatise codifying the boundaries of civil and constitutional review.

Issues

  • What constitutes an "error apparent on the face of the record" justifying review under Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC and Article 137.
  • What are the strict limitations on review petitions disguised as appeals in disguise.

Provisions involved

Reasoning

When review is maintainable

Sathasivam, C.J. laid down that review is maintainable only upon: (1) Discovery of new and important matter or evidence which could not be produced after exercise of due diligence; (2) Some mistake or error apparent on the face of the record; (3) Any other sufficient reason analogous to the above.

When review is strictly NOT maintainable

Review is not maintainable: (1) A repetition of old and overruled arguments; (2) Merely because the conclusion is wrong or an alternative view was possible; (3) As an appeal in disguise; (4) On minor omissions that do not affect the core holding.

Decision

Review petition dismissed. Held that no error apparent on the face of the record was established.

Ratio decidendi

Under Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC and Article 137 of the Constitution, review jurisdiction cannot be used as an appeal in disguise or a second opportunity to re-argue concluded points. An error apparent on the face of the record is one which is self-evident and does not require an elaborate process of reasoning or prolonged debate to establish.

Exam points

  • The definitive guide to Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC and Article 137 review jurisdiction.
  • Comprehensive two-part checklist: when review lies vs when review is barred.
  • Definition of "error apparent on the face of the record".

Tags: AIBE, Judiciary, CPC, Order 47 Rule 1, Article 137, Review, Error Apparent

All judgments