Law of Torts

General principles of tortious liability, defences, vicarious and state liability, negligence, nuisance, trespass, defamation, remedies, consumer protection, and motor accident claims (MACT).

Bare Acts: Law of Torts (Common Law & Judicial Precedents), Consumer Protection Act, 2019, Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 (Chapters XI & XII)

General Principles

Liability Principles & Capacity

Specific Torts to Person & Reputation

  • Trespass to Person — Assault and Battery — Assault (reasonable apprehension of force, R. v. St. George, Stephens v. Myers), Battery (intentional application of force, Cole v. Turner); Defences: self defence, expulsion of trespasser, retaking property
  • False Imprisonment & Complete Restraint — Total deprivation of liberty without lawful authority; Knowledge not essential (Meering); Restraint must be complete (Bird v. Jones, Herd v. Weardale Steel, Robinson v. Balmain Ferry)
  • Malicious Prosecution & Abuse of Process — Prosecution by defendant, termination in plaintiff favour (acquittal), lack of reasonable and probable cause, malice in fact, damage (Dr. Abarth v. NE Railway, Wyatt v. White, Balbhaddar Singh)
  • Maintenance and Champerty — Common law intermeddling in litigation vs. champerty (sharing proceeds); Bradlaugh v. Newdegate; Position in India (not per se illegal; test of public policy and bona fides)
  • Nervous Shock & Psychiatric Injury — Recognized psychiatric damage vs. mere grief; Duty and zone of potential danger; Bourhill v. Young (fisherwoman), Wilkinson v. Downton, King v. Phillips, Hambrook v. Stokes, Owens v. Liverpool Corp, Chadwick
  • Defamation (Libel, Slander, Innuendo & Defences) — Libel vs. Slander; Slander not actionable per se & 4 exceptions; Innuendo (Cassidy v. Daily Mirror, Tolley v. Fry); Defences: Justification by truth, Fair comment, Absolute & Qualified Privilege

Specific Torts to Property & Negligence

  • Negligence, Standard of Care & Medical Negligence — Duty of care (Donoghue v. Stevenson neighbour principle), Breach (Bolton v. Stone, Roe v. Minister of Health), Medical negligence (Bolam test, Jacob Mathew), Res ipsa loquitur (Byrne v. Boadle, Modern Cultivators)
  • Contributory Negligence & Alternate Danger — In pari delicto potior est conditio defendentis; Rule of last opportunity (Davies v. Mann donkey case, Butterfield v. Forrester, British Columbia Electric v. Loach); Alternate danger / dilemma principle (Jones v. Boyce coach accident)
  • Occupier's Liability (Invitee, Licensee & Trespasser) — Duty of occupier depending on visitor status: Invitee common interest (Indermaur v. Dames, Stowell's case); Licensee concealed trap (Fairman); Trespasser no duty of care except willful harm (Bates case)
  • Nuisance (Public vs. Private Nuisance, Highway Nuisance & 45-Degree Rule) — Sic utere tuo ut alienum non laedas; Public nuisance (crime & civil s. 91 CPC, s. 133 BNSS) vs. Private nuisance; Abnormal sensitiveness (Robinson v. Kilvert); Malice (Christie v. Davey, Hollywood Silver Fox); Projections over highway (Tarry v. Ashton); 45-degree rule for light and air (Colls v. Home & Colonial Stores)
  • Trespass to Land, Trespass Ab Initio & Jus Tertii — Trespass quare clausum fregit (Entick v. Carrington); Doctrine of Trespass ab initio requiring positive misfeasance, not omission (Six Carpenters' Case, Chic Fashions v. Jones); Remedies (re-entry, mesne profits); Plea of Jus Tertii (Asher v. Whitlock)
  • Conversion, Detinue & Rights of Finders — Unjustifiable denial of plaintiff title to goods (Fouldes v. Willoughby, Richardson v. Atkinson); Rights of finders: "Finder is keeping is a dangerous half-truth" (Armory v. Delamirie chimney sweep jewel, Bridges v. Hawkesworth shop floor, South Staffordshire Water Co. v. Sharman pool rings)

Economic Torts & Business Interference

  • Deceit & Negligent Misstatement — Tort of Deceit (Pasley v. Freeman, Edgington v. Fitzmaurice, Derry v. Peek fraud test); Liability for negligent misstatement & exceptions to Derry v. Peek (Nocton v. Lord Ashburton, Candler v. Crane, Hedley Byrne & Co. v. Heller & Partners)
  • Interference with Business & Trade Torts — Passing Off (White Hudson v. Asian Organisation, Singer Loog), Slander of Title (Malachy v. Soper), Slander of Goods / Trade Libel (Ratcliffe v. Evans), Breach of Statutory Duty (Harley v. Mayoh, Ginty's case), Mayhem (permanent maiming), Foreign Torts (Phillips v. Eyre, Mostyn v. Fabrigas)
  • Tort of Civil Conspiracy — Unlawful combination of two or more persons with predominant purpose to injure plaintiff resulting in overt damage; Crofter v. Veitch, Mogul Steamship Co. v. McGregor, Quinn v. Leathem, Sorrell v. Smith, Allen v. Flood

Remedies, Extinguishment & Modern Statutes

  • Remoteness of Damage & Novus Actus Interveniens — In jure non remota causa sed proxima spectatur; Novus actus interveniens (Scott v. Shepherd squib case, Haynes v. Harwood); Directness test (Re Polemis) overruled by Reasonable Foresight test (The Wagon Mound No. 1, Hughes v. Lord Advocate)
  • Remedies in Tort (Judicial & Extra-Judicial) — Judicial remedies: Damages (Nominal, Substantial, Exemplary/Aggravated — Huckle v. Money nameless search warrant, Contemptuous — de minimis non curat lex), Injunctions, Restitution; Extra-judicial remedies: Distress Damage Feasant (detention of trespassing animal/chattel without hot pursuit), Abatement of nuisance, Expulsion, Recaption, Re-entry
  • Death in Relation to Tort (Actio Personalis) — Maxim "Actio personalis moritur cum persona"; Common law position & statutory abolition (Rose v. Ford, Baker v. Bolton); Indian statutory modifications: Legal Representatives' Suits Act 1855, Fatal Accidents Act 1855, Limitation Act 1963 1-year rule
  • Discharge of Torts — Extinguishment of right of action: 1. Death of parties, 2. Waiver of tort (election of remedies), 3. Accord and satisfaction, 4. Release, 5. Acquiescence, 6. Law of Limitation (1-year bar for libel, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution)
  • Consumer Protection Act, 2019 (Deficiency, Product Liability & Redressal) — Consumer rights, Definition of Consumer, Deficiency in service, Product liability, CCPA, District/State/National Consumer Redressal Commissions
  • Motor Accident Claims (MACT) & Compensation Principles — Motor Vehicles Act 1988 Chapters XI & XII, No-fault liability Section 164, MACT Tribunal Section 165, Assessment of compensation using Multiplier method (Sarla Verma v. DTC, National Insurance Co. v. Pranay Sethi)